Nach Hartz IV: Erwerbsorientierung von Arbeitslosen (gemeinsam mit S.Röbenack u. K.Schierhorn)

!"#"$ %"&'("$"$ ) *+,-" ./0"12'- ) 32$"1 *'(+"$(4$1

!"#$ %"&'( )*+ ,&-.&/01&2.34 '2.&536 713 8&/.2'0910.3 !

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

G2. ,&-.&/01&2.3'2.&536.3 .26.3023326.& O^53;.3P Q .23. U`=19162. Y/.& ;2. &."9.3 850-2&>536.3 ;2.0.& ?.4 H1&EE"_3"$E.3 "5H ;2. a&2.3'2.&536.3 53; %"3;953600'&"'.62.3 713 I.'&1HH.3.3 20' /204 N *69F K.&$"&; I10#$bc9"5;2" d.23>1=H Z%&06F[J 8&4 /.2'.3 H@& -.326 K.9;F !2.;&2691$3/.0#$DH'26536 23 G.5'0#$9"3;J T&"3>H5&'bCFQ!.- e1&> RBBfF R 83H"36 RBBf -"&.3 #"F NJX C299213.3 L.20'53604 /.(2.$.& (569.2#$ "/$D3626 /.0#$DH'26'J O;2. %D9H'. 016"& 01(2"97.&02#$.&5360=H92#$'26 53; $D5H26 23 *1994 (.2'"&/.2'PJ :@&6.3 ^@$9J d"3;.9 ;.& T53>'213.3 713 8&/.2'0E"&>'=192'2>J 23+ :5;2'$ 850' 5F "F Z%&06F[J Y/.& %"&'( $23"50F ;.& L1$3"&/.2'J ^130'"3( RBBBJ M*-&1A"!! $"- /'& _&-"5.('!/5#$ 67# =-'&#*'&-5#$&#@ /'& "5A &'# H&(&# ;&#.&'*. -&$5!-%&-(."-(&'* I'&!&#+ \'&.& `(&-!&$5#$ 1"$ "5A /&# &-.*&# Q!'9) "# /'& L#*&-.93'93*\'"$#7.& &-'#8 #&-#a %'& %'- I&'$&# %7!!&#@ !"5A&# 5#.&-& Q&A5#/& ;&/793 "5A &'#& 67!!)711&# "#/&-& b-7(!&1.'93* 3'#"5.+

K \'& R5.AJ3-5#$&# (".'&-&# "5A &-.*&# >-$&(#'..&# /&. 67# [!"5. \V--& $&!&'*&*&# 07-.935#$.:-7;&)*&. B>'$&#.'##'$& @[5#/&#h+ \&- >'#A!5.. .*-&#$&- C58 15*("-)&'* "5A /'& >-%&-(.7-'&#*'&-5#$&# R-(&'*.8 !7.&- 5#/ :-&)'#(!'9) '# /'& BC7#& /&- >#*)7::&8 !5#$D E27(&-* F".*&!G@ '# /&- .'93 /'&;&#'$&# (&A'#/&#@ /'& '3- H&(&# I5#&31&#/ ;&#.&'*. -&$5!-%&-(."-(&'* A-'.*&# 1J..&#+ K

Als-ob-Arbeiter

Um-jeden-PreisArbeiter

Die Kompensierer

Die Prekären

Die Aussichtsreichen

Tätigkeitsalternativen zu Erwerbsarbeit

Die Verweigerer

Die Selbsttätigen

Keine Erwerbsarbeit

Die Konventionellen

Die Minimalisten

Orientierung jenseits der Erwerbsarbeit

Lücke zwischen normativer Erwerbsorientierung und Realisierungschance

Starke normative Selbstbindung an Erwerbsarbeit

Normative Erwerbsorientierung

7&.$$.8 >'$&#& \"-.*&!!5#$+

T# /&- R5.%&-*5#$ /&. &1:'-'.93&# U"*&-'"!. 3"(&# %'- .'&(&# *c:'.93& >-%&-(.7-'&#*'&-5#$&# (&' H"#$8 I&'*"-(&'*.!7.&# 5#/ :-&)-8 %&-(."-(&'* 7/&- ^!*&-#)-&/'* "5A$ˇ&#@ 51 /&1 ?93'9)."! /&. B_"-*I'.D I5 &#*$&3&#+ R!. F3&A 67# 1&3-&-&# U'#'8e7((&-# 6&-AJ$* &- .&!(.* J(&- &'# 17#"*!'93&. X&**7&'#)711&# 67# &*%" fgg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

6+::./''"$" I":"9"$4"+>% *+" ]/#'7:+>=2 57==7*" 7&5#"34> -& "#47:>"$0 ^55"$)7# 74$> $+"'7$* +$ *"# &$'+>>":)7#"$ ]734)7#=3475>% *7== *+" 1">#"55"$*" ="+> :7$9"# H"+> 7#)"+>=:/= +=>0 ;(# 7::" ,/+#0-#,)-%*.%) 9+:>% *7== *7= N>#")"$ $734 "+$"# #"9&:+"#&$9 =+34 @"*/34 +' #"7:"$ R")"$ +''"# 6"$+9"# *൷:>"$ :0 K+$" 6734="$*" V:&5> -6+=34"$ $/#'72 >+8"$ ^#+"$>+"#&$9"$ &$* K#6"#)=347$3"$ 347#7.>"#+=+"#> *+" U"#7#)"+>&$9=5/#'"$ &$* \7$*:&$9==>#7>"9+"$ *+"="# 1"5#79>"$0 T$=9"2 =7'> &'57==> 7&34 *+" I#&$*.7>"9/#+" *"# ,/+#0-#,)-%*.%) &$>"#=34+"*:+34" XLE"$ 8/$ K#6"#)=/#+"$>+"#&$9"$0 C67 5(# P+$+@/))"# *+" ?&!"$*7#=>"::&$9 7:= 1"#&5=2 >+9" &$* *+" U"#'"+*&$9 8/$ ?.>+8+"#&$9=2 7$5/#*"#&$9"$ D#+/#+> 47>% =>"::"$ "4#"$2 7'>:+34 K$979+"#>"% *+" +4#" X+9."+> 6+" "+$" U/::-"+>)"=34+9&$9 /#97$+=+"#"$ &$* 7&=()"$% 7&5 =/-+7:" V/$>7.>" &$* C"#>=342 -&$9 7)0 G7= 9":+$9> 7::"#*+$9= +''"# $&# 7$2 $>+2 9"$F% *+" =+34 '+>&$>"# +' )(#9"#=3475>:+34"$ K$979"'"$> 9"#7*"-& 7&5/E5"#$% :7=="$ ."+2 $"$ H6"+5": *7#7$% *7== K4#"$2?#)"+> ?$9"=+34>= *"# X7>=734"% *7== =+34 *+" P"4#2 -74: *"# 8/$ &$= )"5#79>"$ R"+=>&$9=)"-+"4"# *"$ I#&$*.7>"9/#+"$ !"#$%&%'#()%*+#,)-%*# .%) &$* ,/+#0-#,)-%*.%) -&/#*$"$ :7=="$ &$* $734 "+$"# #"9&: =>#"2 )"$% :+"!" =+34 "#67#>"$% *7== -&'+$*"=> *+" 1*23.#,)-%*.%) K+$=>"::&$9"$ 7&56"+="$% *+" 9"'"+$4+$ *"# BQ$>"#=34+34>F -&9"=34#+")"$ 6"#*"$0 T$ *"# X7> #"E#"$ ^#+"$>+"#&$9"$ 7$ "+$"' R")"$ @"$2 ="+>= #"9&:+9."+>0 G7)"+ 47$2 *":> "= =+34 &' 4">"#/9"$"% 674#=34"+$:+34 >"'E/#+/$"$ 6&#*"$ "$>6"*"# $+" 7$9""+9$"> /*"# +' H&9" @74#":7$9"# "#2 5/:9:/="# ?#)"+>==&34" $734 &$* $734 7&59"2 9")"$0 ?$ +4#" N>"::" =+$* 7$*"#" ]/#'"$% X+9."+>=5/#'"$ &$* R")"$="$>6(#5" 9">#"2 >"$0 1"+ 9"$7&"#"' \+$="4"$ :7=="$ =+34 &$>"# *"$ 1*23.#,)-%*.%)' -6"+ 347#7.>"#+=>+2 =34" ?&=E#+7"#()/:)"&8"/'") LL "#&0 \ ?#" 7"2+.8("& D"#)(-&8)7"!#"%"+#&&"& )"%"& )#$% ;"%+ :'"+ 6""+ -&B"+;#(("/( ;#( '"+ S9#$%(@V;"%+@W>&"++7"#()/:)#8$&*$ "1* 1$6&+&-$ .)*'"!-$' $&'$/ C/&',&C&D $11 ")5! B2' &!'$' "'$/%"''+$' S$/C91&5!+)'6 ,)/ @/7$/#*"/#$&+ #$6/$&9$'0 *+$11$' 4&$ 6%., 7%'8%.%. 4&$*$ P2/- &' &!/$/ )'&B$/*$11$' F$1+)'6 &' R/"6$; .)*6/$',)'6 7&/4 B2' &!'$' '&5!+ /"+&2'"1&*&$/$'4 #$7A1+&6+0 *2'D 4$/' *5!1A6+ &' 6$,&$1+$ ?$1#*+")*6/$',)'6 )-; T$&17$&*$ -&+ ")*9:!/1&5!$/ C21&+&*5!$/ G$6/:'4)'6 7&/4 4&$ T21$/&$/)'6 B2' .1+$/D '"+&B$' ,)/ @/7$/#*"/#$&+ 6$92/4$/+ )'4 4$/ ?+"+)* 4$/ ./#$&+*12*&6%$&+ "1* O)'%2'B$'+&2D '$11=0 O)'"#!A'6&6= 24$/ O7&4$/*+A'4&6= ")9D 6$7$/+$+; ($#$'*7$1+1&5!$ G$,)6*2/4')'6$' *&'4 C21&+&*5!$ 24$/ *)#%)1+)/$11$ ?,$'$'0 "#$/ ")5! $+!'&*5!$ P$+,7$/%$; ?215!$ *2,&"D 1$' G$,&$!)'6**+/)%+)/$' *&'4 $&' '2+7$'4&D 6$/ )'4 7&/%*"-$/ @/*"+, 9:/ *2,&"1$ I'+$6/"D +&2' &' )'4 4)/5! @/7$/#*"/#$&+; ?&$ 6$7A!D /$' &- U$6$19"11 >$/+*5!A+,)'60 #&$+$' V/&$'+&$/)'6 )'4 ?+"#&1&+A+ )'4 %2-C$'*&$D /$' ")9 )'+$/*5!&$41&5!$ >$&*$ ")5! J%2'2D -&*5!$' W"'6$1; I- F$6$'*"+, ,) 4$' "'4$D /$' )'*+&,-./%'&%.# B$/9:6$' 4&$ 6%.7%'8%.%. 4"-&+ !A)9&6 :#$/ $&'$' /$1"+&B 7$&+$' *2,&"D 1$' X"'41)'6*%2'+$Y+0 4$/ $&' Z#$/1$#$' "U"'4$ 4$/ F$*$11*5!"9+ $/-J61&5!+; >&$ *&5! 4"* 1"'69/&*+&6 ")9 4&$ @/7$/#*2/&$'+&$/)'6

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`a bcddef gSe# >1 aU gc# (%"* >1 gg F1 X H'.1 61 L1 @5%!"* 3"%C."*# 2%" >/6%5.-&*,+&,* 2",&-?(.5!)-1 J,* '"-"..-?(5F&.%?("! 9!&$%?+.,!' 8%& "%!"* L%.5!6 6,* H"*"%!%',!'# Y%"-05)"! cdde`# >1 ceg FF1

c`

D[,J jj U j`_cddX

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